News
Court Upholds Custodial Sentence for Firewood Sales Fraud
The Panevėžys Regional Court heard a criminal appeal case regarding online fraud and decided to dismiss the appeal filed by the convicted defendant, Eimantas Kaleckas. The court upheld the judgment of the court of first instance, which imposed a final consolidated sentence of one year of actual imprisonment.
The Regional Court stated that, given E. Kaleckas’s prior convictions and negative character assessment, more lenient measures or a suspended sentence would fail to achieve the objectives of justice.
According to case records, the victim found an advertisement on a social networking site for firewood for sale and agreed on its purchase and delivery. However, after transferring the agreed amount to the specified bank account, the buyer never received the firewood. Later, Eimantas Kaleckas contacted the victim again and demanded an additional fee, falsely claiming it was intended for the State Tax Inspectorate to cancel the invoice and process a refund. The victim made a second transfer, yet never recovered the promised funds. The total value of the property obtained by deception amounted to nearly 850 euros.
Disagreeing with the first-instance court's verdict, the defendant requested in his appeal that his sentence be mitigated and its execution suspended. E. Kaleckas did not deny his guilt, stated that he was remorseful, had given up gambling, and had started attending an addiction treatment program. He also argued that an actual prison sentence would hinder his ability to work and compensate the victim for the damages incurred. The prosecution disagreed with the defendant's position and requested that the verdict remain unchanged.
After reviewing the case, the judicial panel noted that Eimantas Kaleckas had already been convicted under previous court judgments for six criminal offenses – five time for identical acts of fraud and once for extortion. The court emphasized that the defendant is unemployed and committed the new offense while other pre-trial investigations were ongoing and a remand measure was in effect. It was also noted that the defendant did not enter rehabilitation on his own initiative, but merely in compliance with a previous court order requiring him to undergo treatment for addictive disorders.
In assessing the possibility of suspending the sentence, the Regional Court remarked that "the application of all the aforementioned legal provisions mitigating the defendant's legal situation, as well as the remand measure, failed to achieve their objectives and did not deter the appellant from committing a new criminal offense."
The court further pointed out that the case file contains no evidence of the defendant's official employment or legal income; therefore, his claims that actual imprisonment would impede his ability to compensate for damages are based solely on assumptions.
Taking into account Eimantas Kaleckas’s negative character profile and his record of prior convictions, the court concluded that only an actual final consolidated sentence of imprisonment will ensure the implementation of the principle of justice and protect society from new crimes.
The ruling of the Panevėžys Regional Court entered into force on the day of its pronouncement.
When citing or otherwise distributing this information, please indicate the source of the information.
Contact for the media:





